Engagement Ring Buying Made Simple: Tips & FAQs

In my experience as a jeweller in Toronto, one of the biggest mistakes people make is focusing too much on certifications, particularly GIA. Many clients believe that a GIA certificate guarantees the best quality, but I’ve seen firsthand that even GIA grades can sometimes be inconsistent or overrated. I’ve had clients compare a GIA-certified diamond to another diamond graded by a reputable lab like IGI or AGS, and the non-GIA diamond often outperforms it in terms of brilliance and overall appearance. Yet, people often still choose the GIA diamond simply due to the brand’s reputation, even if the grading is inaccurate.

I want to be clear: I’m not saying you shouldn’t get a GIA certificate — GIA is a respected grading lab. However, it's essential to ensure you’re getting the **right** GIA certificate, with accurate grading that reflects the true quality of the diamond. Unfortunately, the grading system in the industry often does not work in favor of the consumer; it tends to favor diamond dealers who have established relationships with grading companies. This can sometimes lead to inflated grades that benefit the seller rather than providing an accurate assessment for the buyer.

Another mistake I frequently encounter is relying too much on what you read on Google. While online research can provide valuable information, it cannot replace the experience of actually seeing the diamond with your own eyes. Articles and guides often emphasize the importance of certifications and the Four Cs, but they miss the real-life nuances, such as how a diamond interacts with light or how its cut influences sparkle.

At Design by Sevan I always encourage clients to go beyond the certification and the internet. I take the time to guide them through the process of evaluating diamonds in person, showing side-by-side comparisons from different grading labs, and helping them understand what truly makes a diamond special. My goal is to ensure you select a diamond that looks incredible to your eyes, not just on paper.

In short, don't just rely on Google or a certificate alone — trust your jeweler, trust your eyes, and make sure you're getting the right grading for the diamond you're investing in.

Tiger prongs have sharp, angular edges that offer a bold, modern look while securely holding gemstones. Ideal for those seeking a contemporary style.

Best For: Engagement rings, modern designs, secure settings.

What Are Rounded Prongs?

Rounded prongs have smooth, curved edges, offering a classic, timeless design. They provide a softer, elegant look while securely holding stones.

Best For: Traditional engagement rings, classic designs.

Which Prong Style is Better?

• Tiger prongs: Modern, angular, secure grip.
• Rounded prongs: Classic, softer, timeless look.

Best For: Choose tiger prongs for a bold design and rounded prongs for a classic feel.

Which Prong Style is Safer for Diamonds?

Tiger prongs offer a more secure grip for diamonds due to their angular edges. Rounded prongs still offer solid security but with a softer hold.

Which Prong Style Works Best for Colored Gemstones?

• Tiger prongs highlight vibrant gemstones with a bold look.
• Rounded prongs offer a classic setting that complements all gemstones.

Best For: Tiger prongs for bold stones, rounded prongs for classic gems.

How to Choose the Right Prong Style

Consider your gemstone shape and desired aesthetic:

• Tiger prongs for modern, edgy designs.
• Rounded prongs for classic, timeless style.

How to Care for Prong Settings

Regularly check and clean prongs to ensure your gemstones are secure. Have them professionally inspected to maintain their condition.

Diamonds are timeless, durable, and classic, making them the most popular choice for engagement rings. They offer unmatched brilliance and sparkle, symbolizing strength and eternity. Ideal for those seeking a traditional and elegant look.

Best For: Classic style, timeless elegance, durability.

Why Choose a Color Gemstone?

Color gemstones offer a wide variety of hues, allowing you to personalize your ring with a unique pop of color. Gems like sapphires, emeralds, and rubies are not only beautiful but also symbolize different meanings. They’re perfect for someone looking for a distinctive and vibrant style.

Best For: Unique, vibrant style, personalized symbolism.

Which Is More Durable: Diamonds or Color Gemstones?

Diamonds are the hardest natural material on Earth, making them the most durable choice. Color gemstones, like sapphires, are also durable but may be more prone to scratches or damage depending on the type of gemstone.

Best For: Diamonds for maximum durability, color gemstones for unique yet durable choices.

Which Fits Your Style?

• Diamonds: For a timeless, elegant look.
• Color Gemstones: For a personalized, bold statement.

Best For: Choose diamonds for a classic, enduring design, or color gemstones for a vibrant, custom style.

How to Care for Your Gemstone or Diamond Engagement Ring

Both diamonds and color gemstones require care to maintain their brilliance. Regular cleaning and professional inspections will help keep your ring in top condition.

Best For: Regular cleaning, safe storage, professional inspections.

Whether you choose diamonds for their brilliance or color gemstones for their unique beauty, each option offers something special. Consider your style, budget, and the symbol you want to represent when choosing the perfect engagement ring.